I selected the three individuals, dr martin luther king, henry david thoreau, and mohandas karamchand gandhi, because they dealt directly with nonviolent means to accomplish favorable settlements either through writing or demonstrations the major concepts of this unit will include dr martin luther king's views on. These are the questions explored in the following unit, pairing thoreau's seminal texts “resistance to a civil government” and “a plea for captain john brown” with dr martin luther king, jr's “letter from birmingham jail” and malcolm x's “ ballot or the bullet” essential questions: ○ is civil disobedience a morally. Preparation instructions review the excerpts from henry david thoreau, mahatma gandhi, martin luther king, jr, and daniel berrigan about civil disobedience and dissent in america lesson activities activity 1: defining unjust and just laws - class discussion 1 ask students to define what makes a law unjust or just a. Point out that many people today are inspired by martin luther king, jr but he, too, was inspired by others according to the article, one of his greatest inspirations was civil disobedience, an essay written by henry david thoreau nearly 200 years ago instruct students to conduct research to find a famous.
Martin luther king, jr did you think of henry david thoreau his is not a name currently associated with the idea of civil disobedience but in the 1840s, he literally wrote the book on the topicwell actually, he wrote the essay thoreau's essay civil disobedience or resistance to civil government, published in 1849, is a. Compare and contrast: letter from birmingham jail and civil disobedience henry david thoreau and martin luther king jr both attempt to argue for the rights to disobey authority if there is social injustice thoreau analyzes the duty and responsibility of citizens to protest and take action against corrupt. Henry david thoreau, a philosopher, naturalist, social reformer and author, is best known for walden, or life in the woods, his account of two years in the wilderness in his hometown of this is a draft of the sermon dr king wrote comparing a story from the bible in st luke to the struggle to obtain equality and civil rights. Martin luther king and henry david thoreau both believed that one should stand up for what he believes in, as wells as accepting the consequences for his actions even though they also had different views about what makes law just or unjust first of all, martin luther king believed that a law that is just should be square.
Henry david thoreau's writings influenced both martin luther king and mahatma gandhi in 1931, gandhi told american he urged hindus and muslims to treat one another kindly “remembering that the same divine spirit inhabits whether it is the hindu body or muslim body” on hindu-muslim conflict. Three men who were dedicated to justice and equality in america were thomas jefferson, henry david thoreau, and martin luther king, jr each of these lived to in his time, this most logically meant all white men, and not women, blacks, or other minorities all three men may be compared in their pursuit of rebellion.
No one energized the idea of civil disobedience in the united states more than martin luther king jr he was a student of philosophy and religion and was very aware of thoreau and gandhi no doubt their powerful ideas reinforced his own thinking but it was the reality of racial segregation that led him. Get in-depth analysis of letter from birmingham jail, with this section on compare and contrast. In his letter from birmingham city jail, martin luther king jr compares himself to a number of historical and religious figures here are when martin luther king, jr was in jail in birmingham in april 1963, he wrote a letter to his fellow ministers also, king clearly borrows from henry david thoreau when he writes.
Free essay: comparing marting luther king jr and henry david thoreau martin luther king jr and henry david thoreau were both people who were sent to he also believes that one person's vote or participation can make a difference thoreau holds that majority and nothing can change that both men were put in jail.
The great marches king and his followers organized built a movement not only by following in the footsteps of the great american forefathers who demanded freedom and equality for all his call to conscience also borrowed from henry david thoreau, the great american essayist and author of “walden” who wrote on civil. Comparing and contrasting thoreau and mlk if there was a law that the public felt to be unjust, who would stand up and call it into question henry david.
The term 'civil disobedience' was coined by henry david thoreau in his 1848 essay to describe his refusal to pay the state poll tax implemented by the the resistance to british rule in india led by gandhi, the us civil rights movement led by martin luther king jr, rosa parks and others, the resistance to. Read this full essay on comparing civil disobedience by henry david thoreau and martin luther king's letter from birmingham jail a little rebellion no in other words, if a law denies the right of the minority or is inflicted upon the minority by force, then it is not a just law similar opinions are shared by thoreau, when. Dr martin luther king giving his i have a dream speech during the march on washington in washington, dc, on 28 august 1963 on march 31, 1968, just no other person has been more eloquent and passionate in getting this idea across than henry david thoreau, king wrote in his autobiography. Students examine the role of policies and law(s) versus personal responsibility to promote social justice in classrooms, schools and communities “civil disobedience,” by henry david thoreau “letter from birmingham jail,” by rev martin luther king, jr discussion points should address the following questions: • what is.